1951: Harold Brittan; David Brown; William Fryer; John McGuire; Robert Morrison; Peter Renzulli; Thomas Swords.

1952: George Tintle.

1953: James Douglas; John Jaap.

1954: Aldo Donelli.

1955: Thomas Duggan.

1956: No Inductees.

[an error occurred while processing this directive]>1957: No Inductees.

1958: Francis Rya.

1959: Ralph Carrafi.

1960: No Inductees.

1961: No Inductees.

1962: No Inductees.

1963: Rudolph Kuntner.

1964: No Inductees.

1965: Fred Beardsworth; Teddy Glover.

1966: Stanley Chesney.

1967: No Inductees.

1968: Arnold Oliver.

1969: No Inductees.

1970: No Inductees.

1971: Gene Olaff; Bertram Patenaude.

1972: No Inductees.

1973: Joseph Gryzik.

1974: Nicholas Diorio; James Dunn; Werener Mieth.

1975: Alexander Weir.

1976: Walter Bahr; Frank Borghi; Charles Colombo; Geoff Coombes; Robert Craddock, Jr.; Joe Gaetjens; Gino Gard; Harry Keough; Joseph Mac; Edward McIlvenny; Gino Paria; Edward Souza; John Souza; Frank Wallace; Adam Wolanin.

1977: John Hynes; Bernard McLaughlin.

1978: Raymond Bernabei; Albert Zerhusen.

1979: Albert Harker.

1980: John Boulos.

1981: No Inductees.

1982: Joseph Carenz.

1983: George Barr.

1984: No Inductees.

1985: No Inductees.

1986: Andrew Auld; Mike Bookie; James Brown; Thomas Florie; Jimmy Gallagher; James Gentle; Bart McGhee; Geroge Moorhouse; Philip Slone; Raphael Tracey; Frank Vaughn; Alexander Wood.

1987: No Inductees.

1988: No Inductees.

1989: Walter Dick; Robert Gormley; Werner Roth; Willy Roy.

1990: William O’Brien.

1991: Rudolph Getzinger.

1992: Efrain Chacurian; Werner Fricker.

1993: John Nanoski; Pele Edson Arantes do Nascimento.

1994: Pat McBride; Llyod Monsen.

1995: Rober Annis; George Brown; Willy Schaller.

1996: Nicholas Kropfelder; Len Oliver.

1997: Paul Da; Alexandre Ely; Johnny Moore; Jimmy Roe.

1998: Franz Beckanbauer; April Heinrichs; Edward Murphy.

1999: No Inductees.

2000: Giorgio Chinaglia; Carin Jennings.

2001: Rick Davis; William Looby.

2002: Adolph Bachmeier; Vladislav Bogicevic; Shannon Higgins.

2003: Carlos Alberto Torres; Paul Child; Karl-Heinz Granitza; Arnie Mausser; Bobby Lenarduzzi; Patrick Ntsoelengoe; Alan Willey; Bruce Wilson.

2004: Michelle Akers; Paul Caligiuri; Michael Windischmann; Eric Wynalda.